| Auteur |
Message |
Sujet: Speed up play by always rolling CPs right to left. |
MarkK
Réponses: 16
Vus: 920
|
Forum: Rules question V4 Posté le: Ven Sep 11, 2026 8:58 am Sujet: Speed up play by always rolling CPs right to left. |
| Unless the pixels have suddenly started flowing through the Straits of Hormuz, I’m not sure there’s any particular harm in expressing an opinion on a free and open forum. It’s not as if this fo ... |
Sujet: Speed up play by always rolling CPs right to left. |
MarkK
Réponses: 16
Vus: 920
|
Forum: Rules question V4 Posté le: Jeu Sep 10, 2026 8:19 pm Sujet: Speed up play by always rolling CPs right to left. |
| I’d probably add that Kevin is right in his original post: the principle behind activating one corps at a time is fundamentally flawed. Players are effectively being asked to predict the outcome of ... |
Sujet: Speed up play by always rolling CPs right to left. |
MarkK
Réponses: 16
Vus: 920
|
Forum: Rules question V4 Posté le: Jeu Sep 10, 2026 6:01 pm Sujet: Speed up play by always rolling CPs right to left. |
Or perhaps we could simply let people play the game they want to play and enjoy it, rather than trying to impose our own preferred way of playing on everyone else.
Agree, reasonable sensible compro ... |
Sujet: Speed up play by always rolling CPs right to left. |
MarkK
Réponses: 16
Vus: 920
|
Forum: Rules question V4 Posté le: Mer Sep 09, 2026 10:05 am Sujet: Speed up play by always rolling CPs right to left. |
Or perhaps we could simply let people play the game they want to play and enjoy it, rather than trying to impose our own preferred way of playing on everyone else.
Sometimes, quite often in fact, a ... |
Sujet: Getting the rules V4 |
MarkK
Réponses: 1
Vus: 435
|
Forum: Others topics Posté le: Mar Juil 14, 2026 10:05 am Sujet: Getting the rules V4 |
I bought mine from Caliver books at a show, but they sell it online as well.
https://www.caliverbooks.com/bookview.php?id=29759 |
Sujet: Unmaneuverable units in a group |
MarkK
Réponses: 29
Vus: 6367
|
Forum: Rules question V4 Posté le: Lun Juin 22, 2026 10:41 am Sujet: Unmaneuverable units in a group |
Some of us are engaging in constructive discussion to try and establish an approximation of a group-level consensus as to how we might all deal with this ambiguity should it arise in future.
As far I ... |
Sujet: Unmaneuverable units in a group |
MarkK
Réponses: 29
Vus: 6367
|
Forum: Rules question V4 Posté le: Lun Juin 22, 2026 10:38 am Sujet: Unmaneuverable units in a group |
Well MarkK and Zoltan
Let me ask you.
A column of two HI Impetuous, one behind the other, charges an enemy MSW which is 1.5 UD away.
How many CP is that?
I would say that the root cause ... |
Sujet: Unmaneuverable units in a group |
MarkK
Réponses: 29
Vus: 6367
|
Forum: Rules question V4 Posté le: Sam Juin 20, 2026 10:51 am Sujet: Unmaneuverable units in a group |
So a column of LI followed by elephant advances into contact (presumably simple support).
Sounds like the LI moved less that 3 UD to make contact; ipso facto the elephant also moved less than 3 UD ... |
Sujet: Alexander I of Epiros (Molossos) |
MarkK
Réponses: 4
Vus: 884
|
Forum: Army lists Posté le: Mer Juin 10, 2026 4:15 pm Sujet: Alexander I of Epiros (Molossos) |
| I was always under the impression that there simply isn't enough information on it other than Phillip II rearmed it in the Macedonian style. Then again it wouldn't be the first army list that was comp ... |
Sujet: Deserts on Hills |
MarkK
Réponses: 3
Vus: 1483
|
Forum: Rules question V4 Posté le: Mer Mai 27, 2026 7:35 am Sujet: Deserts on Hills |
| Aren't these called sand dunes? |
Sujet: Wheeling and the rear corner 'kick out' |
MarkK
Réponses: 11
Vus: 6148
|
Forum: Rules question V4 Posté le: Mer Mar 25, 2026 2:51 pm Sujet: Wheeling and the rear corner 'kick out' |
| That is how I understood it, but thought it worthwhile clarifying. I find single element moves really difficult often resulting in not being able to get them were you want them to be despite being in ... |
Sujet: Wheeling and the rear corner 'kick out' |
MarkK
Réponses: 11
Vus: 6148
|
Forum: Rules question V4 Posté le: Mer Mar 25, 2026 1:31 pm Sujet: Wheeling and the rear corner 'kick out' |
| Not relevant to this discussion, but it does involve wheeling and thought there is no point starting a new one. For a group wheel the illustration shows they pivot on a corner. Is it the same for sing ... |
Sujet: Defender choosing terrain |
MarkK
Réponses: 2
Vus: 1550
|
Forum: Rules question V4 Posté le: Dim Mar 15, 2026 4:04 pm Sujet: Defender choosing terrain |
| It would appear so, always worth checking as you can never be sore you’ve missed something somewhere else. |
Sujet: Defender choosing terrain |
MarkK
Réponses: 2
Vus: 1550
|
Forum: Rules question V4 Posté le: Dim Mar 15, 2026 10:06 am Sujet: Defender choosing terrain |
| So as a defender I can choose 2-4 terrain pieces. So if I choose a river coastal and fail to roll a 4+ meaning I can choose another terrain piece p74. As far as I can see there is nothing stopping me ... |
Sujet: MF Bow swd etc. |
MarkK
Réponses: 1
Vus: 2538
|
Forum: Army lists Posté le: Mar Mar 10, 2026 1:29 pm Sujet: MF Bow swd etc. |
| I'm still waiting for the HC/Jav so the Thessalians can have their moment in the sun. |
| |