| Auteur |
Message |
Sujet: Deployment and command range |
Zoltan
Réponses: 16
Vus: 509
|
Forum: Rules question V4 Posté le: Jeu Aoû 06, 2026 7:28 am Sujet: Deployment and command range |
| That’s for sending an order to move a group, not a unit. If you try to do something with a unit it of command range but part if a group not doing the action, then the unit is out of command range. D ... |
Sujet: Deployment and command range |
Zoltan
Réponses: 16
Vus: 509
|
Forum: Rules question V4 Posté le: Mer Aoû 05, 2026 6:56 pm Sujet: Deployment and command range |
| P.26, left column, sentence 2. The definition of command range clearly allows for units OR groups (of units) to satisfy the requirement of being within command range. |
Sujet: Charge and ZOC |
Zoltan
Réponses: 8
Vus: 627
|
Forum: Rules question V4 Posté le: Lun Juil 27, 2026 6:59 pm Sujet: Charge and ZOC |
@Madaxeman
P.31 methinks.
The example picture shows units starting in a straight line.Â
But your view is that “adjacent†covers any scenario where friendly units start touching each othe ... |
Sujet: Charge and ZOC |
Zoltan
Réponses: 8
Vus: 627
|
Forum: Rules question V4 Posté le: Dim Juil 26, 2026 7:53 pm Sujet: Charge and ZOC |
Agreed - scenario 2 charge is NOT permitted.
Even if the blue friend on the right pays 1 CP to advance to “cover the ZoCâ€, I think the charge would NOT be permitted. The permission for a charge ... |
Sujet: Rout and Pursuit Sequencing/Ordering |
Zoltan
Réponses: 2
Vus: 224
|
Forum: Rules question V4 Posté le: Lun Juin 22, 2026 7:37 am Sujet: Rout and Pursuit Sequencing/Ordering |
P.23 Rout and Pursuit
"Routs and pursuits are carried out after the resolution of all combats for all army corps."
So at the time your victorious unit is hit in the flank by a pursuer, ... |
Sujet: Unmaneuverable units in a group |
Zoltan
Réponses: 29
Vus: 5569
|
Forum: Rules question V4 Posté le: Dim Juin 21, 2026 2:26 am Sujet: Unmaneuverable units in a group |
Well MarkK and Zoltan
Let me ask you.
A column of two HI Impetuous, one behind the other, charges an enemy MSW which is 1.5 UD away.
How many CP is that?
Could be 0 CP:
Front impetuous ... |
Sujet: Unmaneuverable units in a group |
Zoltan
Réponses: 29
Vus: 5569
|
Forum: Rules question V4 Posté le: Sam Juin 20, 2026 6:24 am Sujet: Unmaneuverable units in a group |
So a column of LI followed by elephant advances into contact (presumably simple support).
Sounds like the LI moved less that 3 UD to make contact; ipso facto the elephant also moved less than 3 UD ... |
Sujet: Attached commanders |
Zoltan
Réponses: 18
Vus: 1817
|
Forum: Rules question V4 Posté le: Sam Juin 20, 2026 3:51 am Sujet: Attached commanders |
P.27 is clear.
"When a commander is attached to a unit, he stays attached to it until the end of the game-turn..."
Q. Does this mean at the end of the game-turn the commander is no longe ... |
Sujet: Destruction of light infantry |
Zoltan
Réponses: 3
Vus: 386
|
Forum: Rules question V4 Posté le: Mar Juin 09, 2026 7:48 pm Sujet: Destruction of light infantry |
 |
Sujet: Destruction of light infantry |
Zoltan
Réponses: 3
Vus: 386
|
Forum: Rules question V4 Posté le: Mar Juin 09, 2026 9:01 am Sujet: Destruction of light infantry |
P.62 deals with the “auto destruction†of LI.
If LI would be the “main unit†in a melee against specified heavier troop types, no melee is fought - the LI are “auto-killedâ€.
In your ... |
Sujet: Conforming in Multilple attacks |
Zoltan
Réponses: 4
Vus: 942
|
Forum: Rules question V4 Posté le: Sam Mai 23, 2026 7:49 pm Sujet: Conforming in Multilple attacks |
These days I simply can’t be bothered trying to work out what those cryptic letters, numbers and dashes mean. Misinterpretations of the questions often lead to incorrect answers.
Suggest you post ... |
Sujet: Charge and evade |
Zoltan
Réponses: 4
Vus: 2108
|
Forum: Rules question V4 Posté le: Ven Mar 06, 2026 4:47 pm Sujet: Charge and evade |
1. Is the enemy unit fighting C, a target of A's charge? No. (You can't engage in combat with an enemy already engaged in combat). The enemy LI is A's only target.
2. Did A's initial target (the en ... |
Sujet: Incomplete conformation and disengage |
Zoltan
Réponses: 11
Vus: 3920
|
Forum: Rules question V4 Posté le: Mer Fév 04, 2026 5:46 pm Sujet: Incomplete conformation and disengage |
Resolving an incomplete conformation is a housekeeping device when a melee is continuing.
Disengage is a tactical decision to end the melee.
Don’t mix the two things.
A unit in melee (even ... |
Sujet: 80 Warring States - Qin |
Zoltan
Réponses: 4
Vus: 3783
|
Forum: Army lists Posté le: Ven Jan 30, 2026 7:34 pm Sujet: 80 Warring States - Qin |
| I thoroughly recommend the 2024 Netflix documentary Mysteries of the Terracotta Warriors. Lots of "historical re-enactment" sequences interspersed with the archeology and the story telling. ... |
Sujet: Disengage and Multiple Attacks |
Zoltan
Réponses: 18
Vus: 6208
|
Forum: Rules question V4 Posté le: Mar Jan 20, 2026 10:02 am Sujet: Disengage and Multiple Attacks |
l read it as Spear was hit on front and flank by cav. Cav on front broke off so it must be the spear's turn next at which point it would turn and face the threat on its flank non?
Non.
During th ... |
| |