| Auteur |
Message |
Sujet: Impassable river and road |
ethan
Réponses: 26
Vus: 469
|
Forum: Rules question V4 Posté le: Ven Nov 07, 2025 11:11 pm Sujet: Impassable river and road |
Ambrose Burnside has views on this...though perhaps not the best argument...
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Burnside%27s_Bridge |
Sujet: Figures and Depictions in Tournaments |
ethan
Réponses: 6
Vus: 1343
|
Forum: Tournaments and Events Posté le: Mar Jan 21, 2025 3:50 am Sujet: Figures and Depictions in Tournaments |
| At least in the case of Samurai I think this is a bit of the "rule of cool." Everyone has seen Kurosawa films (which tend to be in the 16th Century vein) and the sashimono banners, etc. Th ... |
Sujet: Plumbata or Martiobarbuli |
ethan
Réponses: 4
Vus: 8650
|
Forum: Army lists Posté le: Mar Jan 14, 2025 1:53 am Sujet: Plumbata or Martiobarbuli |
Two items
-I think this could be an interesting option. It is at least a plausible interpretation of later Roman troops. It shouldn't include impact, I am agnostic on middle support - without mis ... |
Sujet: Are Medium Cav Bw priced right? |
ethan
Réponses: 19
Vus: 5233
|
Forum: Rules question V4 Posté le: Jeu Jan 09, 2025 2:59 am Sujet: Are Medium Cav Bw priced right? |
Maybe's aye and maybe's no, I honest don't see the attraction
When playing tournament style ancients a key skill is to get better value from your troops and army design. So if you think there ... |
Sujet: Are Medium Cav Bw priced right? |
ethan
Réponses: 19
Vus: 5233
|
Forum: Rules question V4 Posté le: Mer Jan 08, 2025 11:19 pm Sujet: Are Medium Cav Bw priced right? |
| With only a couple of exceptions I generally feel the points costs in this game are correct and internally consistent. MC Bow are not an exception. I see vastly more MC Bow on the table than HC Impet ... |
Sujet: Spontaneous charges during uncontrolled charges? |
ethan
Réponses: 8
Vus: 1351
|
Forum: Rules question V4 Posté le: Mer Oct 30, 2024 10:08 pm Sujet: Spontaneous charges during uncontrolled charges? |
| I think it is a reminder you can do a spontaneous charge in this case and avoid the negative combat modifier. |
Sujet: #245 French Ordonnonance |
ethan
Réponses: 2
Vus: 7602
|
Forum: Army lists Posté le: Jeu Oct 17, 2024 2:22 am Sujet: #245 French Ordonnonance |
| 2. I believe. |
Sujet: Pyrrhic Italian list |
ethan
Réponses: 15
Vus: 26216
|
Forum: Army lists Posté le: Mer Oct 02, 2024 10:08 pm Sujet: Pyrrhic Italian list |
When I last poked around with Pyrrhus this is what I went with (and a fortified camp)
Strategist
2 Greek horsemen Light cavalry javelin ----------
2 Elephants Elephant ----------
2 Brutti ... |
Sujet: Basing LMI? |
ethan
Réponses: 10
Vus: 11568
|
Forum: Miniatures and painting Posté le: Lun Fév 19, 2024 4:08 pm Sujet: Basing LMI? |
Really the key here is
A) Do something that looks nice
B) Do something that makes it clear what your troops actually are
In general for LMI/MI I do a variety of things 6-8 figures per base (ev ... |
Sujet: How many times may a commander fight in a turn? |
ethan
Réponses: 4
Vus: 1231
|
Forum: Rules question V4 Posté le: Jeu Fév 08, 2024 1:09 am Sujet: How many times may a commander fight in a turn? |
| Don't have my rules with me, but I believe nothing is removed until all combats are resolved. So only once per turn. |
Sujet: #189: 13th Century Communal Italian |
ethan
Réponses: 5
Vus: 10702
|
Forum: Army lists Posté le: Dim Déc 31, 2023 10:01 pm Sujet: #189: 13th Century Communal Italian |
I generally try to create options for visually differentiating units in the army.
So as KevinD noted I might use armored horses for elite units. Further...I might do something like:
- 4 stands ... |
Sujet: Order of St John List 263 |
ethan
Réponses: 2
Vus: 1968
|
Forum: Army lists Posté le: Jeu Oct 05, 2023 2:48 am Sujet: Order of St John List 263 |
| This is why tournaments need both dates and specific restrictions (e.g. armies before 1330AD and no heavy knights or foot knights). |
Sujet: List 232 Scots Mediaeval - suggestions |
ethan
Réponses: 3
Vus: 4133
|
Forum: Army lists Posté le: Mar Aoû 29, 2023 10:10 pm Sujet: List 232 Scots Mediaeval - suggestions |
| As long as the overall end result is kinda right therefore, I’d be tempted to ignore the “pike means very long pointy stick† thing and rationalise it as “they are a unique edge case where th ... |
Sujet: Historicon 2023 |
ethan
Réponses: 12
Vus: 2916
|
Forum: Tournaments and Events Posté le: Jeu Juil 27, 2023 1:18 pm Sujet: Historicon 2023 |
Thank you Dan.
I add armour to my elephants, don't find the elephants vulnerable in melee without armour?
Elephants really need to win impact and armour doesn't help with that. That extra point ... |
Sujet: NZ Nationals eastercon |
ethan
Réponses: 2
Vus: 969
|
Forum: Tournaments and Events Posté le: Mer Mar 22, 2023 11:28 pm Sujet: NZ Nationals eastercon |
| I commend the variety of armies present, I don't think there is a single repeat! |
| |