Art De La Guerre

[KevinD]

I wonder what the factors are for Kn Impetuous charging LI Jav in rough. Kn are -1 (1-2 and no Impact bonus.) I think the LI are only 0 as they don’t count Javelin because their opponents had impact (even though it was cancelled by terrain), no?

Against LMI Javelin it’s 0 vs 0, no? LMI are 0 vs Kn and no Javelin bonus. Kn are 0 (2-2 and no impact). Given armor for knights this is not a great fight for LMI Javelins.

[Zoltan]

Deleted.

[KevinD]

It occurred in a battle reported posted on this forum yesterday.

[madaxeman]

[Mike Bennett]

[Mike Bennett]

[Neep]

It is regrettable that questions this straightforward tend to fester, leading to bizarre conversations over whether asking rules questions in the "Rules questiop V4" forum is a wanton abuse of the "Rules question V4" forum.

[Neep]

Actually Mike, the third bullet on page seems to clearly, if obscurely, indicate that during flank/rear attacks dice effects of Special Abilities are discarded, but their cancelation effects remain.
As I understand it, there was a lot of tweaking to get the outflanking effects well balanced, and perhaps this was one of the tweaks. No indication that it extends to other situations.

[Zoltan]