Art De La Guerre
Bienvenue sur le forum de discussion de la règle de jeu l'Art De La Guerre
 
FAQFAQ RechercherRechercher Liste des MembresListe des Membres Groupes d'utilisateursGroupes d'utilisateurs S'enregistrerS'enregistrer
ProfilProfil Se connecter pour vérifier ses messages privésSe connecter pour vérifier ses messages privés ConnexionConnexion
351 résultats trouvés
Art De La Guerre Index du Forum
Auteur Message
  Sujet: Shape of Village on a Hill
SteveR

Réponses: 6
Vus: 310

MessageForum: Rules question V4   Posté le: Mar Oct 27, 2026 4:24 am   Sujet: Shape of Village on a Hill
I prefer the hill conforms to the village as the village is the terrain pick. There is not a hill already there.
Also it avoids three pages of debate over the parts of the hill not covered by the vi ...
  Sujet: Shape of Village on a Hill
SteveR

Réponses: 6
Vus: 310

MessageForum: Rules question V4   Posté le: Dim Oct 25, 2026 10:38 pm   Sujet: Shape of Village on a Hill
The village occupies the entire hill.

Page 75.

"In this case the hill is entirely covered by the village"

And the shape of the hill is not affected just because a village is on it. ...
  Sujet: Impetuous moving short - or are they?
SteveR

Réponses: 14
Vus: 1190

MessageForum: Rules question V4   Posté le: Dim Aoû 30, 2026 5:51 pm   Sujet: Impetuous moving short - or are they?
Hi Mark,

Your question was perfectly reasonable and it is one that everyone had at one point. So keep asking. Facebook is good for instantaneous answers and it is easier to post pictures but suff ...
  Sujet: Impetuous moving short - or are they?
SteveR

Réponses: 14
Vus: 1190

MessageForum: Rules question V4   Posté le: Sam Aoû 29, 2026 3:25 pm   Sujet: Impetuous moving short - or are they?
They chose to make a move that did not use up all of their movement allowance. They could have remained stationary or moved in a different way but they chose to do this.

When you choose to make a ...
  Sujet: Evade after conformation
SteveR

Réponses: 2
Vus: 568

MessageForum: Rules question V4   Posté le: Lun Aoû 17, 2026 11:39 pm   Sujet: Evade after conformation
The group can evade.

Page 47. Evade procedure

First sentence

"by a unit or by all or part of a group"

yes, it says "charge" later but there is only one evade procedure
  Sujet: Deployment and command range
SteveR

Réponses: 16
Vus: 1891

MessageForum: Rules question V4   Posté le: Dim Aoû 09, 2026 3:12 am   Sujet: Deployment and command range
The more usual question is where the CinC has to be positioned if only some of the units are in ambush. 

The Answer is that the CinC must be deployed on the table and in range of the ambush marker ...
  Sujet: Sgian Dubh 2026
SteveR

Réponses: 10
Vus: 5054

MessageForum: Tournaments and Events   Posté le: Lun Juin 29, 2026 6:43 pm   Sujet: Sgian Dubh 2026
some very interesting army choices there. I look forward to hearing how things go.
  Sujet: Unmaneuverable units in a group
SteveR

Réponses: 29
Vus: 7460

MessageForum: Rules question V4   Posté le: Mar Juin 23, 2026 10:13 pm   Sujet: Unmaneuverable units in a group


But it is a shame that the DT comment is to dismissively say that it is clear and no FAQ is needed. In actual fact what is clear from the comments is that it has not been, and should not be, play ...
  Sujet: Unmaneuverable units in a group
SteveR

Réponses: 29
Vus: 7460

MessageForum: Rules question V4   Posté le: Dim Juin 21, 2026 3:24 am   Sujet: Unmaneuverable units in a group


To the question of impetuous HI in column, if the leading unit can make contact then the group pays 1 CP (the second unit is still part of the group and is therefore ignored).

This is what I be ...
  Sujet: Unmaneuverable units in a group
SteveR

Réponses: 29
Vus: 7460

MessageForum: Rules question V4   Posté le: Sam Juin 20, 2026 9:05 pm   Sujet: Unmaneuverable units in a group
Well MarkK and Zoltan

Let me ask you.

A column of two HI Impetuous, one behind the other, charges an enemy MSW which is 1.5 UD away.

How many CP is that?
  Sujet: Unmaneuverable units in a group
SteveR

Réponses: 29
Vus: 7460

MessageForum: Rules question V4   Posté le: Sam Juin 20, 2026 3:58 am   Sujet: Unmaneuverable units in a group
I was the fellow who brought this question up originally so let me clarify what was going on. It was not a case of continuing a charge at all.

I had a LI in front of an elephant. The elephant is, ...
  Sujet: Attached commanders
SteveR

Réponses: 18
Vus: 3883

MessageForum: Rules question V4   Posté le: Sam Juin 20, 2026 3:37 am   Sujet: Attached commanders
Hi all,

Gavin - I am not sure what you are getting at, that BP does not seem to address the issue.

Tim - I agree that if the last sentence said "He" instead of "it" it would ...
  Sujet: Attached commanders
SteveR

Réponses: 18
Vus: 3883

MessageForum: Rules question V4   Posté le: Mar Juin 16, 2026 7:06 pm   Sujet: Attached commanders
There is a fundamental issue problem when we both don't do what the rules actually say but then (like I have in the past in response to a question) also tell people to just read the rules to see what ...
  Sujet: Attached commanders
SteveR

Réponses: 18
Vus: 3883

MessageForum: Rules question V4   Posté le: Mar Juin 16, 2026 12:00 am   Sujet: Attached commanders
That is interesting. I had not noticed (or seen anyone play that way)

So, for example, a commander is attached to a unit in a group to help move the group. Once the unit in the group he is attach ...
  Sujet: Deserts on Hills
SteveR

Réponses: 3
Vus: 1738

MessageForum: Rules question V4   Posté le: Lun Mai 25, 2026 12:46 am   Sujet: Deserts on Hills
I asked this some time ago and was told "no"

Though it seemed reasonable to me

my suggestion that you should be able to put a gully on a hill and negate both features was also rejected ...
 
Page 1 sur 24 Aller à la page 1, 2, 3 ... 22, 23, 24  Suivante
Toutes les heures sont au format GMT
Sauter vers: