Art De La Guerre

Andy when this matter arose during your game the other night, were you able to resolve it amicably with your opponent and quickly move on?

Zoltan - Andy is putting together a list of issues and resolutions raised in this forum and elsewhere. This will form the basis of a document indicating how issues will be umpired at the Worlds next ...

Seriously Andy??!!

How often does this actually come up, and will the game’s outcome depend on the timing?

Andy is there a particular reason you are raising this hackneyed question now (e.g. you lost a game recently solely due to this issue or perhaps you have too much time on your hands )? Wink

A n ...

I was thrown by this comment:
In the case of no obstacles en route, if the evading unit made an initial quarter or half turn to first reorientate before its straight line evade move, the general mo ...

But the evade move rules do not actually say anything about slowing terrain.

As Madaxeman has said ad nauseum, the structure of the ADLG rules is general rules followed by special rules that may qu ...

I really don't understand why you guys are agonising over this.

The issue is not terrain within 1UD, that is clear. It is delaying terrain further away.

The page 48 rule is all about whether o ...

I really don't understand why you guys are agonising over this.

Sure, the page 48 Second case blocked evade heading uses the word "obtstacle" in a different way compared to page 67. But p ...

At the time it routed (when the final cohesion loss was applied) the unit was being attacked on its front edge (the camels had not yet disengaged).

Thus we ignore the rule that says, “If at the t ...

Dickstick

P.9 Routed

“When a unit has lost all its cohesion points, it is routed…..It is eliminated and removed from the battlefield at the end of the current Phase.”

So a unit routed i ...

P.9 makes it clear that a unit routed during the Movement phase is removed from the table at the end of that phase (last sentence). So the OP situation no longer exists once the game has moved to the ...

P.9 makes it clear that a unit routed during the Movement phase is removed from the table at the end of that phase (last sentence). So the OP situation no longer exists once the game has moved to the ...

Dickstick.

P.9 spells out that all units are always in one of three statuses:

Good order
Disordered
Routed

P.23 spells out the sequence of play in phases:

Movement
Shooting
Combat
R ...

no

Thank you for your answer - is there a reference to the rule that covers this?

Andy

Impetuous units have an exemption from making an uncontrolled charge (p.46) if that would result in them ...

So are you saying the rout should be done immediately in the movement phase? Ie before the break off from melee?.

No, I’m pointing out that there is a distinction between when a unit status moves ...