Art De La Guerre

1. Is the enemy unit fighting C, a target of A's charge? No. (You can't engage in combat with an enemy already engaged in combat). The enemy LI is A's only target.

2. Did A's initial target (the en ...

Resolving an incomplete conformation is a housekeeping device when a melee is continuing.

Disengage is a tactical decision to end the melee.

Don’t mix the two things.

A unit in melee (even ...

I thoroughly recommend the 2024 Netflix documentary Mysteries of the Terracotta Warriors. Lots of "historical re-enactment" sequences interspersed with the archeology and the story telling. ...

l read it as Spear was hit on front and flank by cav. Cav on front broke off so it must be the spear's turn next at which point it would turn and face the threat on its flank non?

Non.

During th ...

It would take a cohesion hit from the initial hit, I would assume it would turn and face the HC still in contact to it's flank.
Yes and no. The spear do not turn (it's the cav's phase) and are now th ...

A well-considered summary to end the year Mark.

I perfectly understand your point an out timing. It is irrelevant.

If you were in melee during the melee phase and your commander was either included or engaged, you must test if you take a. Hit d ...

I perfectly understand your point an out timing. It is irrelevant.

If you were in melee during the melee phase and your commander was either included or engaged, you must test if you take a. Hit d ...

Per point d above. No, if the commander is engaged and the unit routs, then the commander is lost on a 1-3. See bullet #3, p 28.Totally correct.

Sorry Zoltan, there is no ‘timing issue’ here. ...

Per point d above.

No, if the commander is engaged and the unit routs, then the commander is lost on a 1-3. See bullet #3, p 28.

My point d explained in detail:

My unit is in melee with your ...

So:

a. included commander, unit not in melee
If his unit routs (for any reason) - no test: commander is automatically lost (p28).

b. attached commander, unit not in melee
If his unit routs - n ...

I've found this a rather confusing discussion, so just to be clear:

A unit with an included commander is NOT in melee.

However, a friendly unit just got routed and the included commander's unit ...

Dates: Saturday 4 and Sunday 5 April 2026 (Easter).

Venue: Hataitai Centre (ex Bowling Club)
157 Hataitai Road, Hataitai, Wellington 6021
https://hataitai.org.nz/hataitai-centre

Organiser: Ste ...

Hi from New Zealand!

I want to come to your tournament 9-10 Mai 2026. Does anyone speak English please?

Merci!
Stephen Ladányi

For pedants (ce moi), the Charge rules (pp.43 etc) are a tad inconsistent in that the text in different paragraphs swings between single unit and group charges, and single / multiple initial targets. ...